Best tenant screening for a single landlord
With one unit you screen maybe once every year or two, so a subscription rarely makes sense. Pay-per-report services and the screening built into free rent apps are the realistic choices.
No affiliate links on this site yet. If that changes, it will say so here and on the disclosure page.
How we verify: every fee and plan price on this page is taken from the vendor page linked in the source line, read on Nov 19, 2026. This is not a personal test of the product.
Compared
| Service | Price | Who pays | Checks | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RentPrep Complete | $49 | Landlord or tenant | TransUnion credit + nationwide criminal, evictions, judgments/liens | Background reviewed by FCRA-certified screeners; Stessa says 1–2 business hours |
| SmartMove Premium | $49 + tax | Landlord or applicant (where permitted) | ResidentScore, credit, criminal, eviction, income estimate, ID check | Most reports same day after applicant verifies identity |
| SmartMove Plus | $42 + tax | Landlord or applicant | ResidentScore, credit, criminal, eviction | Same as above |
| Zillow | $40 | Renter | Experian credit, CIC background, eviction history | Included in the application; renter can reuse for 30 days |
| RentRedi | $39.99 ($49.99 with income) | Tenant | TransUnion credit, criminal, eviction | Part of RentRedi subscription |
| TurboTenant | $55 ($45 if landlord on Pro) | Renter by default | Credit, criminal, eviction | Part of TurboTenant application |
| Innago | $30–35 (+$10 income) | Applicant by default | Credit, criminal, eviction | Free platform |
Sources: RentPrep packages, Stessa screening help, SmartMove pricing, Zillow tenant screening, RentRedi pricing, TurboTenant pricing, Innago FAQ. Checked Nov 19, 2026.
How to choose
- You want a person to look at the background check: RentPrep's Complete package is the only one here whose page says the background check is reviewed by FCRA-certified screeners.
- You don't use any landlord software: SmartMove and RentPrep work on their own; you send the applicant a link.
- You already list on Zillow: its $40 renter-paid application includes credit and background, and renters can reuse it for 30 days.
- You collect rent in RentRedi, TurboTenant or Innago: screening in the same app keeps the application, report and lease together. See TurboTenant vs Innago.
Rules on application fees and which records can be used vary by state and city. Check yours before you charge an applicant.
Real questions behind this page: "what the gold standard is", screening service recommendations (r/Landlord).
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a software subscription to screen one applicant?
No. SmartMove and RentPrep work as stand-alone reports: you send the applicant a link. The screening built into TurboTenant, RentRedi, Innago or Zillow is convenient if you already use that app.
Which report is reviewed by a person?
RentPrep's Complete package is the only one in this table whose page says the background check is reviewed by FCRA-certified screeners.