Landlord Field Guide

Tenant screening for small landlords

Screening prices are small next to a bad tenancy, but they vary a lot in what you get. These are the published prices and contents.

No affiliate links on this site yet. If that changes, it will say so here and on the disclosure page.

How we verify: every fee and plan price on this page is taken from the vendor page linked in the source line, read on Nov 19, 2026. This is not a personal test of the product.

ServicePriceWho paysWhat's in it
TransUnion SmartMovePremium $49; Plus $42; Basic $25; Background Check Basic $25; income verification +$11 (plus tax)Landlord or applicant (where permitted)Premium: ResidentScore, criminal, credit, eviction, income estimate, ID check
RentPrep (via Stessa)Credit only $29; Background only $29; Complete $49; income +$10; income + employment +$15Complete and Credit: landlord or tenant. Background only: landlord paysComplete: TransUnion credit + nationwide criminal, evictions, judgments/liens, reviewed by an FCRA-certified screener
TurboTenant$45 if landlord is on Pro; $55 otherwise (page shows Pro and Free tabs)Renter pays by default; landlord can payCredit, criminal and eviction checks
RentRedi$39.99; $49.99 with income verificationTenantTransUnion credit, criminal, eviction
Zillow Rental Manager$40 application feeRenter (reusable for 30 days at participating rentals)Experian credit report, CIC background check
Innago$30–35; income verification +$10Applicant by defaultCredit, criminal, eviction
BaselaneFrom $24.99 ("$24.99+")Listed under tenant feesNot detailed on pricing page
Rentec DirectStarter: $14.95–$29.45. Pro/PM: $10–$18Not stated on pricing pageBasic package: nationwide criminal, sex offender, SSN validation
AvailNot published (pricing page says costs vary by location)Tenant (most common) or landlordCredit, criminal, eviction

Sources: SmartMove pricing, RentPrep packages, Stessa screening help, TurboTenant pricing, RentRedi pricing, Zillow tenant screening, Innago FAQ, Baselane pricing, Rentec Direct pricing, Avail pricing. Checked Nov 19, 2026.

Before you pick

Landlords ask this a lot: "what's the gold standard?" and one landlord who lost trust in a service after it "missed multiple felonies".

Frequently asked questions

Can the applicant pay for the screening?

Often yes, where local rules allow it. SmartMove and RentPrep Complete/Credit say the landlord or applicant can pay. TurboTenant, RentRedi, Zillow, Innago and Avail list the renter or applicant as the default or typical payer. RentPrep's Background-only package says the landlord pays. Check your state and city before charging an applicant.

What is actually in a typical report?

Most packages on this list include a credit report plus criminal and eviction searches. SmartMove Premium also lists ResidentScore, an income estimate and an ID check. RentPrep Complete says the background check is reviewed by an FCRA-certified screener. Baselane's pricing page lists a starting price but does not detail the report.